How do they compare?
- Installation: floating units go into a working tank on moorings; diffusers usually need the tank emptied
- Capital cost: floating units avoid bridges, floor pipework and a blower house
- Maintenance: floating units are reached from the edge with no diving; diffusers sit on the floor
- Flexibility: floating units can be moved or added as load grows
- Depth: floating aerators suit 0.5 to 5 metres
- Gas stripping: surface splashing drives out hydrogen sulfide and methane
When are diffusers the better choice?
Steady activated sludge tanks where the floor can be reached for maintenance and energy use per kg of oxygen is the main concern.
Which uses less energy?
Fine bubble diffusers usually transfer more oxygen per kWh. The US EPA design manual for fine pore aeration gives typical clean water efficiencies of about 6.5 lb O2 per hp hour for fine bubble, 3.0 for mechanical surface aerators and 2.0 for coarse bubble, which is roughly 4.0, 1.8 and 1.2 kg O2 per kWh. That is why Uisce Éireann's energy programme has replaced surface aerators with fine bubble diffusers at some plants it is rebuilding.
Energy is not the only cost. Diffusers need the tank emptied to install and to repair, floor pipework and a blower house. Floating aerators go into a working tank with no civil works, which is why they are used to add oxygen quickly, cover a shortfall, keep a tank running while diffusers are repaired, aerate balancing and sludge tanks, and serve tanks that cannot be taken out of service. We will tell you when a diffuser system would suit your plant better.
Sources: US EPA, Design Manual: Fine Pore Aeration Systems (1989), as cited by Lawrence Berkeley National Laboratory, Fine Bubble tipsheet (industrialapplications.lbl.gov); Uisce Éireann project pages (water.ie).